This
piece, of course, is a classic and I don’t think that there is a high school
student in the US who hasn’t had to read it at one point or another during
their grade school education. Considering this, one is forced to look at the
play in a way as to determine what it is about this particular text that so
many school districts and educators find so important.
I
understand that as a work the language and structure of this classic piece is
remarkable and any student would benefit from being introduced to writing such
as this. I also understand that as the main characters are teenagers themselves
and are struggling with something that virtually every teenager goes through
(that of love and loss), this text is something that teenagers can relate to,
and, as far as Shakespeare goes, it is fairly simply written. What I don’t
really get, and have never really gotten about this work is that it has always
struck me as a bit on the whiney side and full of over-reaction to what is a
romance that spans the whole of 2 or 3 days.
While I
do realize that high school students (myself included) often over-react to
everything in their lives, it seems that there are works by Shakespeare that I
think students would benefit more from and that have just as good, if not
better, language, structure and plot. I would personally prefer to use some of
Shakespeare’s comedies in the high school classroom. These texts would
introduce students to the same beauty of language and would allow them to
experience the funny side of Shakespeare, a side that I think is often under-represented
in the high school classroom.
No comments:
Post a Comment